Why Shoes Hurt Us + 5 Reasons to Ditch the Shoes
Shoes may be the most accepted health hazard in modern culture. We wear them without question, but few stop to ask what they’re really doing to our bodies. From bunions to back pain, poor posture to poor balance, shoes may be one of the greatest “normal” practices that quietly sabotage human health.
It’s not just about comfort—it’s about culture. In the West, bare feet are often seen as a sign of poverty or neglect, when in reality, they represent freedom, strength, and natural human movement.
For me, ditching shoes especially when I’m home, gardening, or walking the dog wasn’t a quirky lifestyle choice. It was a way back to health. And once you understand what shoes really do, you might want to leave them behind too.
1. Shoes Are Painful & Unnatural
A Wall Street Journal report found that two-thirds of Americans are wearing the wrong shoe size, suffering from pain, bunions, hammer toes, and other conditions. Feet change over time with age, weight, pregnancy, and activity—but shoes rarely accommodate this.
Footwear also alters our gait and makes us “defective walkers,” as Dr. William Rossi (consultant to the footwear industry) put it:
“All shoeless people are the only pure walkers on the planet. All the rest of us, by grace of the shoes we wear, are defective walkers in varying manner or degree.”
My own turning point was when I tried walking two miles in new moccasins—tight, blistering, unbearable. Halfway through, I took them off and continued barefoot in total comfort. That was the last summer I wore shoes regularly.
2. Shoes Disfigure Feet
Decades of podiatric research show the damage caused by modern footwear. Dr. Simon Wikler, a pioneer in podiatry, put it bluntly:
“There is now no question in my mind… THE MAJOR CAUSE OF FOOT TROUBLE IS THE TYPE OF SHOES WE WEAR.”
Cultures that live barefoot have strong, wide, healthy feet with little to no deformities. By contrast, habitual shoe wearers often develop bunions, collapsed arches, and toes squished into a triangular shape. Since going barefoot, I see these deformities everywhere—and I want no part of them.
3. Shoes Disrupt Balance, Stability, & Coordinatio
Shoes don’t just disfigure feet—they disrupt the entire body’s mechanics. Dr. Rossi again noted:
“Natural gait and shoes are biomechanically incompatible… no therapy or mechanical device can fully reverse the gait from wrong to right.”
When you strip away shoes, you regain balance, agility, and natural foot strength. Walking barefoot strengthens stabilizing muscles and restores natural posture—something no expensive orthopedic insert can replicate.
4. Shoes Create Health Problems
Contrary to what many believe, foot pain often comes from shoes—not from going barefoot. A survey published by the Journal of the National Association of Chiropodists found that populations in India and China who never wore shoes had almost no foot problems.
Issues like plantar fasciitis are often blamed on barefoot living, yet modern shoes—with elevated heels and excessive cushioning—are usually the real culprit. For me, decades of restrictive footwear contributed to chronic back pain. Once I ditched shoes, my back pain disappeared. If I start wearing shoes regularly again, the back pain comes back.
5. Shoes Are Simply Not Necessary
Humans evolved over four million years with bare feet. Shoes are a modern invention that compromise form, function, and even our microbiome (since soil contact boosts immune health). Dr. Rossi once summarized it perfectly:
“We have converted a beautiful thoroughbred into a plodding plowhorse.”
The truth is: most of the time, we don’t need shoes. We’ve just been conditioned to think we do. The freedom of walking barefoot—feeling the earth, building strength, and moving naturally—far outweighs the false sense of security shoes provide.
The Benefits of Going Barefoot
If you’ve never experienced life without shoes, you might wonder what the real advantages are. Scientific research and experience point to some surprising benefits:
Strength & posture: Walking barefoot engages muscles and nerves in the feet and legs, naturally improving stability and alignment.
Ground connection: Direct contact with the earth improves sensory feedback, allowing your body to move with better coordination.
Stress reduction: Grounding (touching bare feet to natural surfaces) helps calm the nervous system, shifting it from “fight-or-flight” into “rest and reset.”
Healthier foot mechanics: Free feet stay strong and flexible, avoiding the weakening and stiffness modern shoes encourage.
Cognitive boost: Even research from the National Institutes of Health suggests barefoot walking may improve brain function—particularly in younger people.
How to Get Started Going Barefoot
Like any lifestyle change, it helps to ease in:
Start gradually: Begin with 15–20 minutes on soft ground like grass, sand, or smooth dirt.
Choose safe terrain: Be mindful of sharp objects or hazardous surfaces.
Explore minimalist options: If full barefoot feels intimidating, try minimalist shoes that mimic the natural feel while still offering protection.
Listen to your body: Allow your feet and muscles time to adapt—strength builds with consistent, gentle practice.
The Takeaway
Going barefoot isn’t about rejecting culture for the sake of rebellion—it’s about returning to the way our bodies were designed to move. If you want a compromise for cold months, there are minimal barefoot shoes designed to protect while preserving natural foot function. But whenever possible, let your feet breathe, spread, and connect with the ground.
Ditching shoes may feel radical at first. But once you experience the freedom, balance, and relief it brings—you may never go back.
The Scientific Research
2024 – Kim
Effects of Barefoot Walking in Urban Forests on CRP, IFNγ, and Serotonin Levels
Walking barefoot in forest environments (a form of grounding plus green exercise) has been shown to lower cortisol, increase relaxing alpha brainwaves, enhance NK immune cells, and boost antioxidant enzymes like superoxide dismutase.
2024 – Kim
Barefoot walking improves cognitive ability in adolescents
A 12-week study had adolescent participants walk barefoot four times weekly. Results included shifts in EEG patterns—lower gamma and H-beta waves and increases in SMR and alpha waves—plus improvements in concentration, cognitive speed, and reduced brain stress.
2022 – Kim
Barefoot walking improves EEG measures of attention and reduces stress in adolescents
Walking can have a positive impact on cognitive function in adolescents. This study aimed to compare the effects of walking with sneakers and barefoot on cognitive ability in adolescents.
2022 – Sinatra
Grounding - The universal anti-inflammatory remedy
In one study, just 20 minutes of grounding led to measurable improvements in HRV, suggesting a quick calming effect on the nervous system.
2022 – Koniver
Practical Applications of Grounding to Support Health
Summarizes that grounding (i.e., conductive contact with Earth) has been shown to deepen restorative sleep and normalize cortisol rhythms.
2022 – Breet
Are habitually barefoot children compelled to wear ill-fitting shoes?
Current school shoes sold in stores don’t fit well for children who grow up barefoot. Manufacturers should make wider shoes to prevent long-term foot problems in these kids and teens.
2022 – Ren
Barefoot walking is more stable in the gait of balance recovery in older adults
Walking barefoot may improve balance training in older adults, since their steps are more consistent than when wearing shoes.
2021 – Curtis
Daily activity in minimal footwear increases foot strength
Adults wearing minimalist shoes for six months saw a 57.4% average increase in foot muscle strength, leading to better balance and gait mechanics.
2017 – Hollander
A multicenter epidemiological study was conducted to compare the foot morphology between habitually barefoot children and adolescents and matched counterparts that are used to wearing shoes. Found that barefoot-raised kids had wider feet, stronger arches, and better flexibility.
2015 – Oschman
This overview highlights that grounding deepens restorative sleep, normalizes the day–night cortisol rhythm, helps relax muscles, and boosts mood.
2004 – Ghaly & Teplitz
The Biologic Effects of Grounding the Human Body During Sleep as Measured by Cortisol Levels and Subjective Reporting of Sleep, Pain, and Stress
A pilot study where participants slept grounded on conductive mattress pads for 8 weeks. Results showed significantly reduced nighttime cortisol levels, a more normalized 24-hour cortisol rhythm, and improvements in sleep quality, pain, and stress perception.
Shoes linked to common foot deformities
Urry, S. et al. (2021). Relationship of short footwear to the prevalence of foot deformities. Journal of Foot & Ankle Research.
Too-short shoes directly correlated with deformities and pain.
LinkBarefoot running improves mechanics
Lieberman, D.E. et al. (2010). Foot strike patterns and collision forces in habitually barefoot vs. shod runners.Nature.
Barefoot runners land on the forefoot/midfoot with less impact force.
LinkPlantar pressure differences barefoot vs. shod
Franklin, S. et al. (2015). Barefoot vs. shod walking: biomechanical differences in plantar loading. Gait & Posture.
Shoes significantly change foot strike and loading patterns.
LinkBack pain linked to footwear
Knapik, J.J. et al. (2012). Influence of footwear on musculoskeletal injury risk in military recruits. American Journal of Preventive Medicine.
Restrictive shoes associated with higher rates of back, knee, and ankle injuries.
LinkShoes alter natural posture
Wegener, C. et al. (2011). Effect of children’s shoes on gait and posture. Pediatrics International.
Children in stiff shoes had shorter steps, reduced ankle motion, and altered posture.
LinkBarefoot reduces inflammatory markers
Kim, Y. et al. (2024). Walking barefoot in urban forests reduces inflammatory biomarkers compared to shod walking. Environmental Research.
Lower CRP and IFN-γ after barefoot sessions.
LinkFoot morphology in barefoot vs. shod adults
Rao, U.B. & Joseph, B. (1992). The influence of footwear on the prevalence of flat foot. The Journal of Bone and Joint Surgery.
Flat feet were significantly more common in shoe-wearing populations.
LinkBarefoot balance advantages in older adults
Hatton, A.L. et al. (2013). Effect of footwear on balance and falls in older people. Age and Ageing.
Shoes increased sway and fall risk compared to barefoot walking.
LinkRunning injury risk reduced with barefoot mechanics
Warne, J.P. & Gruber, A.H. (2017). Transitioning to minimal footwear: injury risk and performance. British Journal of Sports Medicine.
Barefoot and minimal runners had lower injury rates once adapted.
LinkShoes alter natural sensory input
Robbins, S. & Waked, E. (1997). Balance impairment in athletic footwear: sensory attenuation hypothesis.Medicine & Science in Sports & Exercise.
Shoes dull sensory feedback, reducing natural balance.
Link
